Ukraine-Russia Talks End Without Ceasefire, Kyiv Rallies Western Support

Ukraine rallied support from its Western allies on Friday after its first direct talks with Moscow in over three years ended without a ceasefire agreement, as Russia proposed conditions that a Ukrainian source dismissed as “non-starters”.

Under pressure from US President Donald Trump to end the bloodiest conflict in Europe since World War Two, delegates from the warring countries met for the first time since March 2022, the month after Russia invaded its neighbour.

Zelenskyy Briefs Trump

The talks in an Istanbul palace lasted well under two hours. Russia expressed satisfaction with the meeting and said it was ready to continue contacts. Both countries said they had agreed to trade 1,000 prisoners of war each in what would be the biggest such exchange yet.

But Kyiv, which wants the West to impose tighter sanctions unless Moscow accepts a proposal from Trump for a 30-day ceasefire, immediately began rallying its allies for tougher action.

As soon as the talks ended, Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelenskyy held a phone call with Trump and the leaders of France, Germany and Poland, his spokesperson said.

Zelenskyy said robust sanctions should follow if Russia rejected a ceasefire.

Demands ‘Detached From Reality’

Russia’s demands were “detached from reality and go far beyond anything that was previously discussed,” a source in the Ukrainian delegation told Reuters.

The source, speaking on condition of anonymity, said Moscow had issued ultimatums for Ukraine to withdraw from parts of its own territory in order to obtain a ceasefire “and other non-starters and non-constructive conditions”.

British Prime Minister Keir Starmer said the Russian position was “clearly unacceptable” and that European leaders, Ukraine and the US were “closely aligning” their responses.

EU’s New Package Of Sanctions

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said the EU was working on a new package of sanctions against Moscow.
Russia’s lead negotiator, Vladimir Medinsky, told reporters his team had “taken note” of the Ukrainians’ request for direct talks between Zelenskyy and President Vladimir Putin. Putin, after proposing the direct talks, had spurned a challenge from the Ukrainian leader to meet him personally in Istanbul.

“We have agreed that each side will present its vision of a possible future ceasefire and spell it out in detail. After such a vision has been presented, we believe it would be appropriate, as also agreed, to continue our negotiations,” Medinsky said.

Crediting efforts by Trump and other US officials, Kirill Dmitriev, Putin’s investment envoy, said on X the talks produced “good results…1. Largest POW exchange, 2. Ceasefire options that may work 3. Understanding of positions and continued dialogue.”

No Movement Until Trump-Putin Meet?

Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha wrote on X that he and EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas agreed that “pressure on Moscow must be strengthened to achieve a full and durable ceasefire”.

Writing separately on Facebook, Sybiha said the talks were positive if only for the prospect of prisoners coming home. Zelenskyy said Kyiv’s top priority was “a full, unconditional and honest ceasefire… to stop the killing and create a solid basis for diplomacy”.

The sides mostly repeated known positions. The Ukrainians wanted an immediate ceasefire and talks to ensue, while the Russians demanded more talks before agreeing on a ceasefire.

Expectations for a breakthrough, already low, were dented on Thursday when Trump, winding up a Middle East tour, said there would be no movement until he and Putin met.

Russia says it wants to end the war by diplomatic means and is ready to discuss a ceasefire. But it has raised questions and concerns, saying Ukraine could use a pause to rest its forces, mobilise troops and acquire more Western weapons.

Ukraine and its allies accuse Putin of stalling, and say he is not serious about wanting peace.

Calm Atmosphere

The negotiating teams sat opposite one another on at a U-shaped table, with the Russians dressed in suits while half of the Ukrainians wore military fatigues.

A Turkish official said afterwards the atmosphere had been calm. No concrete timetable or location was agreed for the next talks, the official said, with both sides needing to debrief their leaders first.

The Ukrainian source said the Ukrainians spoke in their own language, through an interpreter, although Russian is widely spoken in Ukraine.

A Ukrainian and a European source said Russia rejected a Ukrainian request for US representatives to be in the room.

Two sources familiar with the talks said Medinsky said Russia was ready to keep fighting for as long as necessary, drawing a parallel with the wars of Tsar Peter the Great against Sweden that lasted 21 years in the early 1700s.

“We do not want war, but we are ready to fight for a year, two, three — as long as you want,” one of the sources quoted him as saying.

Grinding Advance

Russia said on Friday it captured another village in its slow, grinding advance in eastern Ukraine. Minutes before the start of the Istanbul meeting, Ukrainian media reported an air alert and explosions in the city of Dnipro.

Russia says it sees the talks as a continuation of negotiations, also in Istanbul, weeks after the 2022 invasion.

But the terms under discussion then, when Ukraine was still reeling from Russia’s invasion, would be deeply disadvantageous to Kyiv now. They included a demand by Moscow for large cuts to Ukraine’s military.

With Russian forces in control of about a fifth of Ukraine, Putin has insisted Kyiv cede territory, abandon NATO membership ambitions and become a neutral country.

Ukraine rejects these terms as tantamount to capitulation, and is seeking guarantees of its future security from world powers, especially the United States.

(With inputs from Reuters)