Elon Musk, tasked by President Donald Trump to eliminate government waste, renewed his threat on Monday to fire federal workers who don’t justify their jobs, despite the Trump administration’s statement that workers were not required to respond.
The U.S. agency that oversees federal employees said on Monday they could ignore a weekend email from Musk that required them to summarize their work or face losing their jobs. The directive sparked widespread confusion across the federal government and raised questions about how much actual authority Musk, the world’s richest man, possesses within the administration.
As the deadline for response grew near on Monday, Musk, whom Trump appointed to head up a newly named Department of Government Efficiency that Trump has tasked to radically downsize the government, seemed to acknowledge that his plan had run aground.
“The email request was utterly trivial, as the standard for passing the test was to type some words and press send!” Musk posted on X, the social media site he owns. “Yet so many failed even that inane test, urged on in some cases by their managers.”
Musk went on to say, “Subject to the discretion of the president, they will be given another chance. Failure to respond a second time will result in termination.”
The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Musk’s remarks.
It was unclear whether Musk was aware of the guidance the U.S. Office of Personnel Management released earlier on Monday telling human resources officials at federal agencies that employees would not be let go for not replying to Musk’s email – nor were staff required to respond to it.
The memo said responding to the email was voluntary. It also urged employees not to share confidential, sensitive or classified information in their responses, a concern of critics of Musk’s action.
Even after that guidance was issued, some agencies nudged their employees to respond.
A senior manager at the General Services Administration, which manages federal buildings, told employees that the agency was still encouraging workers to answer the email even if it was voluntary, according to a GSA source.
Similarly, the acting director of OPM itself sent an email to the agency’s staff that said responding with bullet points was voluntary “but strongly encouraged”.
Resistance To Musk’s Order
The Department of Health and Human Services advised employees that if they chose to reply, they should keep their responses general in nature and that they should refrain from identifying specific drugs or contracts they are working on, according to an email reviewed by Reuters.
“Assume that what you write will be read by malign foreign actors and tailor your response accordingly,” the email said.
Musk’s downsizing initiative, known as DOGE, has rippled into the wider U.S. economy as well, forcing companies that do business with the government to lay off workers and defer payments to vendors.
Musk’s Saturday message took some administration officials by surprise, according to two sources familiar with the situation.
Adding to the confusion, Trump stood by Musk. “I thought it was great,” he told reporters at the White House earlier on Monday. “There was a lot of genius in sending it. We’re trying to find out if people were working.”
In other Monday action, a federal judge blocked the government downsizing team created by Trump and led by Musk from accessing sensitive data maintained by the U.S. Education Department and the OPM.
Unlike Cabinet appointees and appointees to head up independent federal agencies, Musk’s appointment required no approval by the U.S. Senate.
Unions Sue Over Musk Email
Also on Monday, a group of labor unions that have asked a federal judge to stop the mass firings updated their lawsuit to request that Musk’s email be ruled illegal.
Prior to the OPM directive, senior officials at the Department of Justice, as well as the Departments of Defense, State and Homeland Security and several other agencies had told workers not to respond outside their established chain of command.
The Transportation Department, the Treasury Department and independent agencies like the Federal Trade Commission and the Federal Communications Commission have told employees to answer Musk’s message.
Musk has reveled in the upheaval, even wielding a chainsaw at a conservative political conference last week.
In addition, his email was sent to political appointees at the White House who presumably would not be viewed with suspicion by the president, according to two sources.
It also was sent to federal judges and other employees of the court system, who make up a separate branch of government and do not answer to the administration.
More than 20,000 workers have been laid off as part of the downsizing effort.
Downsizing, Rehiring
The confusion echoed the broader turmoil surrounding Trump’s return to power.
Since taking office on January 20, Trump has frozen billions of dollars in foreign assistance and effectively dismantled the U.S.
Agency for International Development, which administers some 60% of U.S. foreign assistance, stranding medicine and food in warehouses.
Trump has ordered employees of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau to cease working, though they also received Musk’s email asking that they outline their work activities over the past week. The Trump administration has separately offered buyouts to 75,000 workers.
In some cases, the government has scrambled to rehire workers who perform critical functions like nuclear weapons oversight and bird flu response. The downsizing has prompted a wave of lawsuits.
(With inputs from Reuters)
